Selling to a real estate agent is familiar. Selling directly to a cash buyer like Property 59 is newer territory for a lot of homeowners in Marysville, Bellefontaine, Urbana, Newark, Marion, Springfield, Columbus, and Lancaster — and it’s normal to want to see how it’s gone for other people before trusting us with your own house.
Below, you’ll find real stories from homeowners we’ve worked with — people dealing with inherited properties, difficult tenants, houses that needed more repairs than they could afford, or situations where they just needed to move fast. We don’t cherry-pick the easy ones; we ask everyone we work with if they’d be willing to share their experience, good or bad.
Interested in sharing your own Property 59 experience? Reach out to us and inform us about your journey working with Property 59.
Every review below is from a real homeowner we’ve worked with — no stock photos, no fabricated quotes. Whether someone inherited a property they didn’t know what to do with, needed to close fast because of a life change, or just wanted to skip the hassle of listing, these are the actual situations people brought to us. If you want to see even more, you can also find our reviews on Google and Facebook.
Every house and every seller’s situation is different, which is why we treat every offer individually rather than running everyone through the same formula. Take a look through a few of these stories below, and if you have questions about how we might be able to help with your specific situation, reach out anytime — there’s no pressure and no obligation.
If you’d rather see reviews in a different format, you can also find us on Google and Facebook, where several of these same homeowners have left their feedback directly. Every one of them is from someone we actually worked with and closed a deal with — nothing here is staged or written by us.
Skeptical at First, Glad I Trusted Him
“I was skeptical at first and honestly wasnt sure if this was a scam. Jason was absolutely straightforward and honest the entire time and really helped me out of a hard situation. I highly recommend Jason and Property 59 to anyone needing to sell a property timely and professionally.”
Patient and Communicative Through Probate
“My sister and I worked with Jason after my mom passed away. He bought our mom’s house for a very fair price and was very communicative throughout the whole probate process with us as we had never been through it before. I would definitely recommend him for any property needs!”
Very Knowledgeable. Would Recommend.
“Jason was good to work with very knowledgeable and answered any questions we had. Would definitely recommend”
Emotional and difficult time made easy
“Jason made an emotionaly difficult time for me run smoothly. He was there anytime I had a problem navigating the probate process. I will recommend them to anyone that might be in need. Honesty and integrity were displayed at every curve in the process”
Upfront And Straight Forward
“Jason is upfront and straight forward which is something rare in the real estate business. It might not be what you want to hear but it is the truth. Keep up the good work”
“Flawless Transaction”
I sold a house to Jason last month. The whole transaction went extremely well. Jason made sure everything was taken care of and was done on my terms. He went out of his way to accommodate me through the whole process starting with seeing the house, making an offer, packing, moving, and all the paperwork. It was flawless! I would definitely recommend him to everyone who is thinking of selling. He’s kind, caring, and personable. He’s the real deal. Thanks Jason!
“Upfront and Honest”
“Jason is a good guy to deal with. He made a fair offer on my house and closed within 30 days. He is a up front and honest person and easy to work with. He will not try and scam you like a lot of other people that buy houses and rehab them. I’m happy he got the house I had for sale as it needed more work than I could handle or have time and money to fix. I am very interested in seeing the house get fixed up and I’m sure the neighbors will also be happy that the house is getting fixed up. Thank you for an easy and seamless sale of my house. Keep up the good work
“Fast and Easy”
“Jason Came out to the house and took a look. It needed a lot of work and I didn’t have time to deal with it. He made me an offer that evening and I accepted. We closed fast and within a couple weeks like I wanted. This was a fast and EASY process. Would recommend for anyone who doesn’t want to do work on a house and just wants to move on.”
“We Closed In Two Weeks”
“I had a very positive experience selling my property to them. We closed in less than two weeks.”
“Fair And Honest Business”
“This business is fair and honest. Made me an offer on day one within 30 days money was in the bank. They handled everything I only saw them the day I signed the contract and the day of closing for the notary. If you want to sell without doing the work first they will save you a headache”
